Create a free Industrial Equipment News account to continue

When Recurring Supply Chain Problems Justify an Acquisition

But be careful, vertical integration may simply replace one bottleneck with a more expensive one.

Two professionals in hard hats shaking hands in an industrial manufacturing facility with large machinery.
iStock

Recurring supplier delays, quality problems and capacity constraints can eventually force manufacturers to reconsider not just how they source, but whether they should own a critical part of the supply chain. In that kind of situation, buying a supplier starts to look like a practical way to seize more control, at least on paper.

But taking over a business brings many responsibilities that go well past securing capacity. The buyer also takes on its workforce, operating costs, capital needs and customer relationships. Fixing a supply problem is just one slice of the bigger picture.

Before pursuing an acquisition, manufacturers should ask whether the ownership side will actually address a long-term strategic need, and whether they are ready to run the business that comes with it.

Identify the Problem Ownership Would Solve

If an outside vendor keeps missing delivery dates, supplies inconsistent work or can’t add capacity quickly enough, owning that operation might start to feel like the solution. But you should not treat an acquisition like a quick-fix solution to the most recent disruption, no matter how frustrating it can be.

Instead, it should target a repeatable structural problem the company can’t fix in a smarter way with another supplier, a long-term contract or an internal investment.

The central question is not whether vertical integration removes risk. It does not.

When a company buys a supplier, it trades supply chain risk for a whole new set of operating risks. The deal only makes sense when the leadership team clearly understands the swap and has a specific reason to accept it, even if it sounds counterintuitive at first.

Distinguish Temporary Disruptions From Structural Constraints

Start by distinguishing a temporary disruption from a persistent constraint. In recent years, supply shocks have pushed many companies to reconsider sourcing strategies, add redundant vendors and even move portions of their supply chains closer to home. Those moves could be enough when the problem is mostly geographic, logistical or tied to a single event. But acquisition gets more compelling when the same snag keeps showing up, limiting growth or performance, even after all those measures are taken.

Quality is one example. Think about a company that built its own proprietary product, but it still had to rely on a few third-party manufacturers to make it work. Even if every manufacturer used the same intellectual property and followed the same specifications, the results would not come out quite the same. The company could consolidate production with one manufacturer or set up a joint venture with a vendor to improve supply processes.

One company I worked with that was struggling with this very same issue ended up putting a strategic partnership in place with a vendor. With more command over the process, the situation improved: quality, turnaround time and overall efficiency improved noticeably. Full ownership wasn’t strictly required, but the basic logic was similar. The company needed stronger control over a factor that directly affects customers and, by extension, the brand.

Capacity can create the same pressure. If a company’s qualified vendor base can’t support projected growth, then securing production capacity is strategically important. An acquisition can also help protect intellectual property, reduce exposure to volatile input costs, or bring in an element that is tough to build in-house. In each situation, leaders should be able to identify the exact constraint that they are buying and estimate how much control over it is worth.

Evaluate the Economics Under New Ownership

This analysis must include all the supplier's economics, not just the past numbers in isolation. A supplier may sell to several companies that compete with the prospective buyer today.

Once the buyer owns it, some customers might find a new supplier or move their business elsewhere instead of buying from a competitor. A business that looks appealing based on historical revenue and profit can be less valuable once you factor in potential customer attrition from the change in ownership.

Buyers should model the supplier using realistic ownership assumptions, including customer attrition, capital spending and integration costs.

Know Who Will Run the Business

Leadership also needs to understand what operating the supplier will require. A distributor, retailer or sales-oriented company that acquires a manufacturer may suddenly be responsible for a plant, specialized labor, maintenance capital expenditures, commodity exposure and possibly a union workforce. These are not secondary details. They are core operating responsibilities that can consume management attention and capital long after the transaction closes.

Before moving forward, companies should identify who will run the acquired operation. If the existing leadership team lacks manufacturing experience or the capacity to oversee another business, the target needs to bring strong operators with it.

A capable general manager or plant manager may be as important as the equipment or customer contracts being acquired. If neither the buyer nor the target has that leadership, the acquisition may create a larger problem than the one it was meant to solve.

Consider Alternatives to Full Ownership

An acquisition is also only one option. A strategic investment, joint venture or long-term supply agreement can provide greater access and influence without requiring full ownership. In other cases, the right answer may be less vertical integration.

In one case we observed, a manufacturer had historically produced a broad range of components in-house, including several relatively low-value items that consumed meaningful floor space and production capacity. The company ultimately shifted certain work to qualified third-party suppliers, freeing capacity for higher-value production and allowing it to focus internal resources on the areas where it had the greatest strategic advantage. That example illustrates why the decision should begin with the operating constraint, not with a preference to buy or build. Leaders should determine which activities create a competitive advantage, which require greater control and which can be handled effectively by a partner. The answer may be an acquisition, but it may also be a narrower arrangement that preserves flexibility.

Test the Deal Before Committing

Companies considering a supplier acquisition should use the advisers they already trust, including their M&A adviser, accountant and bank.

Together, they can test the transaction's valuation, financing needs, capital requirements and downside scenarios. Operational diligence should receive the same attention as financial diligence because the buyer will inherit the supplier's day-to-day challenges along with its capacity and capabilities.

Buying a supplier can be a sound response to persistent quality problems, constrained capacity or the need to control critical intellectual property. It works best when the problem is recurring, the economics remain attractive after the ownership change, and the buyer has the leadership to run the business.

When those conditions are absent, vertical integration may simply replace one bottleneck with a more expensive one.

Brent Haapanen is a partner at DCA Partners, where he advises public and private companies on mergers and acquisitions, capital structure and strategic corporate finance decisions.

More in Supply Chain